By John M. Collard
Valuing a Company is the easy part; creating that value in the first place so you can measure it is a more formidable task. Create a Value Equation to build worth into your Company.
Determining value is more art form than science. True value can only be established at the time of a transaction, where the willing buyer tenders payment and the willing seller accepts it in exchange.
Buyers and sellers look at the component make-up of a company differently, and therefore, place different values on these ingredients and on the whole. To enhance the real company value, analyze company components as they relate to worth in the mind of potential buyers. Value to one buyer often does not necessarily hold the same value for another. Establish multiple buyer profiles depending upon the circumstances and prepare to build value each would be willing to pay for.
There are essentially two kinds of buyers —
Strategic and Annuity Buyers, both with different motives. Yet, both demand
returns for their shareholders.
The Strategic Buyer purchases for reasons that fit into their strategic plan. They benefit through synergies like acquiring a customer base in expanded territories, new products, added capacity, and reduced costs, et cetera. This type of buyer may place some value in the first-line of the management team but will see added value in the ability to place their
own managers into key positions.
The Annuity or Financial Buyer, on the other hand, sees value in the stand-alone entity’s ability to generate cash flow from profits year after year. The institutional buyer places the highest value on how motivated and incentivized the existing management team is, and their receptiveness to remain to generate cash and profits. The owner/operator
conversely will look at ‘buying a job’.
Typically, strategic buyers of closely held companies purchase at six to 10 times earnings and/or cash flow, while annuity buyers pay two to six times cash flow. The ultimate worth of the company depends upon who the buyer will be. These multiples are usually considerably higher in public companies, but the concepts of building value are the same.
The essential is to look at what is valuable and understand how to exploit and preserve this value. From the start, plan to sell the business and put value creation into perspective.
Free cash flow and the continued ability to produce it with a reliable probability creates the greatest value. This is not as easy as it sounds. In fact, it can be complicated, is often misunderstood, and frequently is bungled. Look at the elements in the Value Creation Equation to see how each brings forth value and how together they compound the effect.
Value Creation =
Net Asset Value + Future Revenue Stream +
Going Concern Value + Incentive to Purchase
Net Asset Value (NAV)
Sometimes referred to as Orderly Liquidation Value, it is the cash net worth of assets fewer encumbrances if you were to liquidate these assets at a fair market price under orderly disposition conditions when liquidation is not necessary. This NAV can equal Net Worth on the Balance Sheet but is often adjusted for the value of intangibles.
Simply stated: Tangible Unencumbered Book Value + Intangible Assets + Adjustments to Market Value (Over-amortized/depreciated/expensed assets, or usable Inventory is written down lower than market value) – Obsolete Inventory and Bad Debts – Outstanding Obligations on open contracts = market value. Build a strong, healthy balance sheet with
adequate reserves and proper statement of asset value, because this is a
fundamental on which to expand a company and increase its worth.
Tangible assets can be appraised to establish their worth. On the other hand, intangible assets are harder to value because they are subject to interpretation. If you sell a machine you realize cash for the transaction; but if you lose a customer, no one pays you for it, they’re just gone.
Intellectual property is also hard to value, but filing more patents will
generate value, particularly to those who can afford to protect them from
The real opportunity lies not in building an asset base, but in building maximum return on those assets and deployed capital. Assets don’t generate worth by themselves, they can only be used to generate worth. If the asset sits idle, it is actually losing value, but if volume causes the asset to work to produce output production, value is being created.
The closer the relationship of assets to realize $1 for each $1 dollar on the balance sheet the better. Cash and Securities fit this description. Accounts Receivable will be discounted as they age; focus on keeping the days outstanding as low as possible. Utilize percentage completion contracts when possible to keep receivables low and cash flow.
Utilize just-in-time and consignment agreements to keep raw materials at the lowest levels possible to minimize obsolescence.
Produce in-process work expediently to cover short-term needs. Build finished
goods for firm orders or reasonable short-term expectations of sale, don’t
overproduce. If in a reasonable business cover production levels over the
off-season with contracts for the sale of goods just before the season, cover the
risk with orders for goods. It may be better to have less than market demand if
projections were off, compared to interest and carrying costs to hold
artificial Christmas trees until next year.
Customer Lists, contacts, name recognition, trademarks, reputation, Web distribution channels and Internet presence are often not considered in asset valuation because they are not carried on the balance sheet. These assets, however, are often worth considerable value in the market place. The reasoning for this theory is that these assets can be turned
into cash; therefore, should equal the related value they could generate in
return for their sale. These intangible assets can produce future sales,
profits, and cash.
Future Revenue Stream
A real value in any company starts with its revenue stream; the more you can count on it occurring, the more value it has. The value becomes the net present value of the after tax-free cash flow stream of revenue under contract, plus repeat customer base. The contract backlog is worth much more than the revenue that you must locate every year. The cost to re-create the sale each year is high in terms of time and human energy. Locate customers
where multiple-year contract environments can be set up. The government often
awards contracts for multiple year periods. Many larger companies favor
contract relationships with vendors to reduce the overall cost of screening
vendors again and again.
While not as quantifiable as backlog, there is value in a customer base that’s been maintained for a long period of time. The longer customers remain with a company, the more likely they will be loyal in the future. When customers stay with an organization, this is an indication of the value, which they receive from that organization. Conversely, customer turnover indicates their dissatisfaction in the company’s ability to provide
services. For example, software companies retain customers and repeat sales with
product upgrades and gain new customers with import utilities for easy
Clearly growth in revenue volume is an indicator of valuation in a company that investors are willing to pay for. If customers flock at above industry levels to a company for the services that they provide, this is a good indication of the company’s ability to perform at above-expected levels. A motivated sales force with the ability to generate new revenues year after year has more value than a company that has a poor selling reputation. A
lack of growth indicates that the company does not have an ability to increase
its value over time.
When a company has a great, and believable, prospectus for the future, the buyer will often plan additional capital investment to fuel growth. If this case, the buyer could be motivated to pay a higher valuation for the company and then invest on top of it.
Going Concern Value (GCV)
Here is where the fun begins in all transactions. The going-concern value and goodwill, or soft assets, will always draw the most controversy and discussion in terms of their valuation. These elements are most prone to differing interpretations by buyers and sellers.
Here to is where you can build the most value into a company. Transaction value is only at a point in time. Buyers and investors look more to the company’s ability to create additional value to enhance returns on invested capital as they hold their investment. Impart the elements that Future Buyers look for:
Businesses that create value. Consistency is the key. You must demonstrate growth in revenue, profit, and cash flow. Do everything in your power to eliminate and manage ‘hick-ups’ along the way.
Audited statements go a long way toward verifying results, in spite of some recent press.
High probability of future cash flows. A history of positive cash flow at increasing levels is very important. True annuity buyers purchase cash flow, not the business. Strategic buyers will value cash flow plus what could happen if additional capital is provided. After all, free cash flow determines the periodic return on investment and increases the potential for a
much higher purchase price in the future.
The management team and human capital. Attract and motivate a marketing-oriented management team with the ability to produce recurring profits, return on capital, and free cash flow as an annuity for the owners. Develop an in-place; stable, well-trained workforce to implement operating processes on an ongoing basis. This is the most valuable off-balance sheet asset. When the owner of a privately held business has transitioned out
and is collecting the net profit and cash without participating in an active management role, the value increases dramatically.
The ability to sell, compete, distribute, produce, develop products and thrive. This stand-alone entity track record demonstrates the viability of the market relationship between the products/services offered to meet customer demand and needs, the ability of the company to compete, and company reputation in the marketplace. The more unique a product is the more value it contributes to the deal. The company must be able to differentiate its
products and services from the competition, even if this is based mainly on
perception. Remember, products do have a life cycle and require improvements to
remain in demand.
The directors’ and management’s role must be to build Going Concern Value! The GCV can be best maximized with stable leadership, setting and following sound strategies to consistently bring products and services to market, all the while nurturing resources and
implementing processes to manage the company. Here is where the greatest value
Incentive to Purchase
Create reasons for a buyer to want to consider your company as an acquisition candidate. Buyers want a Fair Entry Valuation so that they can expect a realistic return potential. There must be Exit Options so that the buyer who buys your business can realize high ROI at the time they resell.
The better the company is at creating stakeholder value and shareholder return, the more interest there will be in buying some or all of the stock. While investors often buy on hope and promise, the dot com market sector collapse clearly indicates a need to ultimately produce returns to substantiate investment. Think for a moment, had many of the dot com
managers built GCV to support their promising technologies, they might still be
around today. Those that have built GCV have strong balance sheets, can
weather the storm, and will undoubtedly find opportunities to gobble up assets
from those who didn’t.
Build on any one element in the Equation and you increase its individual value. Build up all elements in the Equation and you realize an exponential creation of value to the right buyer. The buyer looking for a standalone entity to produce an annuity stream will place the highest value on the company when all components are strong and it operates with little owner intervention. Buyers looking only for parts of a business to augment
their own will want to invest less and only place value on some components,
regardless of how strong they are. For example, if you build a strong senior
management team, but the buyer wants to run the business, they will place no value
in your senior manager(s) that will be replaced.
Remember, as in Field of Dreams
: “If you build it, they will come.”
Author: John M. Collard
John is Chairman of Strategic Management Partners, Inc. in Annapolis, Maryland. John is a Certified Turnaround Professional (CTP), and a Certified International Turnaround Manager (CITM), who brings over 35 years of senior operating leadership, $85M+ asset and investment recovery, 45+ transactions worth $1.2B, and $80M fund management expertise to run troubled companies, serve on and advise boards of directors, and raise capital. John has parachuted in as the Interim CEO, CRO or senior executive to turn around
troubled entities, and serves as an outside director. John is inducted into the
Turnaround Management, Restructuring, and Distressed Investing Industry Hall Of
Fame. John is Past Chairman of the Turnaround Management Association (TMA),
Past Chairman of the Association of Interim Executives (AIE), and a Senior
Fellow of the Turnaround Management Society. John is the Founder of TMA. John was
honored as Prince Georges Business Leader of the Year. John is honored with the
Interim Management Lifetime Achievement Award from the Association of Interim
Executives. John is honored as Most Admired CEO in Maryland by Daily Record.
John is honored with SmartCEO Distinguished Leadership Award.
Firm: Strategic Management Partners, Inc.
) are a turnaround management firm specializing in board and private equity advisory, asset, and investment recovery, raising money, interim management and executive CEO leadership, and investing in and rebuilding distressed
underperforming troubled companies. The firm has been an advisor to Presidents
Bush (41 & 43), Clinton, Reagan, and Yeltsin, World Bank, EBRD, Company
Boards, and Equity Capital Investors on leadership, rebuilding troubled companies, investment recovery, turnaround management and equity investing. SMP is celebrating 25 years of service to its clients. SMP was named Maryland’s Small Business of the Year, and received the Governor’s Citation, State of Maryland as a special tribute to honor work in the areas of turning around troubled companies and saving jobs in Maryland. Turnarounds & Workouts Magazine twice named SMP among the Top Outstanding Turnaround Management Firms.
American Business Journals named SMP among the Most Active Turnaround
Management and Consulting Firms in Baltimore, Washington, and the Mid-Atlantic
Region. Global M&A Network Turnaround Atlas Awards named SMP as Boutique
Turnaround Consulting Firm of the Year.